“The Assassination of Gianni Versace,” the second season of FX’s “American Crime Story” anthology series, scored 18 Emmy nominations, the most of any limited series this year. Those are spread across 13 categories, which means that if this Ryan Murphy production sweeps all of them it would tie the record currently held by HBO’s “John Adams,” which made history in 2008 by becoming the most awarded limited series of all time and the most awarded program of any genre in a single year.
“Versace” scored a trio of nominations in two categories: Best Movie/Mini Supporting Actor (Edgar Ramirez, Ricky Martin and Finn Wittrock) and Best Movie/Mini Picture Editing (for the episodes “Alone,” “House by the Lake” and “Manhunt”). It also scored double nominations for Best Movie/Mini Supporting Actress (Penelope Cruz and Judith Light).
The show is nominated once apiece in its other 10 categories. It received bids for Best Limited Series, Best Movie/Mini Directing (Murphy for the episode “The Man Who Would be Vogue”) and Best Movie/Mini Writing (Tom Rob Smith for “House by the Lake”). And its star Darren Criss gained his first career acting nomination for Best Movie/Mini Actor. The limited series also received nominations for its casting, costumes, hairstyling, non-prosthetic makeup, prosthetic makeup and sound mixing.
“John Adams” was nominated 23 times across 18 categories and also had multiple nominees in four categories: Best Movie/Mini Cinematography, Best Movie/Mini Sound Editing, Best Movie/Mini Sound Mixing and Best Movie/Mini Supporting Actor (Tom Wilkinson, Stephen Dillane and David Morse). “John Adams” was able to win each of those awards, with Wilkinson prevailing in the acting race.
The other nine victories for “John Adams” were Best Miniseries, Best Movie/Mini Actor (Paul Giamatti), Best Movie/Mini Actress (Laura Linney), Best Movie/Mini Writing (Kirk Ellis for the episode “Independence”) and below-the-line victories for its art direction, casting, costumes, prosthetic makeup, and visual effects. “John Adams” only ended up losing five categories: Best Movie/Mini Directing, plus races for hairstyling, non-prosthetic makeup, picture editing, and music composition.
But “Versace” can’t afford to lose anything if it wants to tie the record, and it will face strong competition from, among others, Netflix’s “Godless,” which scored 12 nominations overall. “Versace” will go head-to-head with “Godless” in seven categories including Best Limited Series. Keep in mind that “Big Little Lies” had fewer nominations than “Feud: Bette and Joan” last year (16 to 18), but ultimately was the big winner with eight trophies including the top prize, so don’t count out “Godless” just because it has fewer noms.
Thirteen wins would tie the record, but if “Versace” wins 12 it would be in second place on the all-time list of the most awarded limited series ahead of “Angels in America,” which won 11 in 2003. Ten would place it third, and nine wins would tie it with Murphy’s big winner from 2016, “The People v. O.J. Simpson,” and the most-watched limited series ever, “Roots” (1977).
‘The Assassination of Gianni Versace’ could tie ‘John Adams’ Emmy record of 13 wins