Screener reaction at Gold Derby forums (SPOILERS for which episodes characters appear in)
I have seen six episodes so far.
Penelope Cruz:
Episode 1: Finally arrives on private jet 37 minutes in
Episode 2: Leaves on private jet 10 minutes in, later in flashback
Episode 3: Absent
Episode 4: Absent
Episode 5: Only in opening 4 minutes
Episode 6: AbsentCruz might end up submitting the second episode because it has her grieving, but it is not a showcase like the third episode for one-off guest Judith Light, the fourth for recurring guest Cody Fern (halfway between Chris Zylka and Domhnall Gleeson) or the fifth for recurring guest Finn Wittrock. Max Greenfield is unrecognizable in the first two episodes. Donatella often appears with her brother Santo, played by Javier Bardem doppelgänger Giovanni Cirfiera.
Ricky Martin is also missing in the third, fourth and sixth episodes. Ramirez is missing in the third and fourth, appears in a dream sequence in the sixth and spends most of the first episode on a gurney. The point is that this is decidedly Darren Criss’s show, even though the credits in the first two episodes are:
Starring Edgar Ramirez
Darren Criss
Ricky Martin
and Penelope CruzThe rest of the screeners did not have credits on them, so I am not sure if people are still credited when they do not appear. Criss is very good, although it is not far off from his performance as Blaine Anderson on Glee. If Blaine were a serial killer instead of a singing teenager, this would be it. There is talk in the Call Me by Your Name thread about how gay guys in film are often played by straight guys seemingly playing straight guys who are apparently gay. Suffice it to say that this is not that.
As for the show itself, it does not live up to The People v. O.J. Simpson or even Bette and Joan. Cult was more entertaining. Despite the title, the show follows Andrew Cunanan on his cross-country killing spree. Is he worthy of such examination though? He is a compulsive liar, so nothing that he says matters. It is a bit repetitive over so many episodes. His victims fit a pattern, but they are all innocent. It is sad that they randomly got killed, but it is sad when innocent people randomly get killed. The show is supposedly about the pursuit of the American dream and the failures of institutions and—most effectively conveyed—how being gay in the nineties sucked, but Andrew being a homicidal psychopath transcends all of that as far as I am concerned, two-thirds into the season.
There is some jumping around early on, but for the most part, episodes are ordered reverse-chronologically. The first eight minutes of the show have almost no dialogue, but the score never stops. It would be a good reel to submit in cinematography as well. The premiere is very well directed by Ryan Murphy, but the show is less dynamic after that. The second episode, directed by the cinematographer, has an excessively warm filter, like when Breaking Bad would go to Mexico.