The year’s best TV shows so far

“The Assassination of Gianni Versace” (FX)

The second season of Ryan Murphy’s true-crime anthology series hones in on the world of fashion, murder and police department homophobia in the late 1990s. Told in an innovative backwards structure, it boasts a career-defining performance from Darren Criss (“Glee”) as serial killer Andrew Cunanan.

The year’s best TV shows so far

FX totally screwed up ‘Versace’ finale

How could FX screw up the ending of “The Assassination of Gianni Versace”?

Don’t believe half of what you saw on Wednesday night’s season finale. It never happened.

Although the credits clearly say “Based on the book ‘Vulgar Favors’ by Maureen Orth,” Murphy and his screenwriter Tom Rob Smith had, up to now, done such a scrupulous job in detailing killer Andrew Cunanan’s descent into madness — minus the weight gain from his crystal meth addiction that made him persona non grata in gay circles.

But they blew it in the end. And fans of the show need to know what really went down.

Note to Hollywood screenwriters: Don’t f - - k up the end of a true-crime story, especially when the facts are there for everyone to read. I know reading is not a big pastime in LA, but the truth is out there.

On page 477 of “Vulgar Favors,” Orth describes how quickly it all went down on the Miami houseboat where Cunanan had been hiding out after shooting Versace in cold blood.

When houseboat caretaker Fernando Carreira saw that the front-door lock was broken, he entered the home at around 3:45 p.m., gun drawn. Orth writes, “As he pulled it out to conduct a search, a loud shot rang out in the second-floor bedroom. ‘It was a very big noise and I have to run out,’ ” Carreira recalls.”

That shot was Cunanan killing himself through the mouth with the gun he stole from his first victim, his friend Jeff Trail (Finn Wittrock).

In Wednesday night’s finale, Cunanan (Darren Criss) sees the caretaker from an upstairs balcony and fires a shot to scare him away. In reality, Cunanan was already dead.

Subsequent scenes of the police closing in, of tear gas canisters being thrown into the houseboat and of the electricity being cut off to trap Cunanan did not happen while he was alive.

Why bend the truth for a Hollywood showdown? This is not an episode of “Mannix.” Up to this point, the series had accurately shown how Versace was killed, filming the murder scene in front of his former Miami Beach mansion, and how the FBI screwed up the investigation — for example, by refusing to let Miami police distribute the Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list photos of Cunanan in gay bars after he’d killed four men but before he killed Versace (Edgar Ramírez). (They did eventually hang flyers, but too late — Cunanan was already dead.)

The finale’s list of inaccuracies goes on.

In real life, the FBI had a difficult time identifying Cunanan’s corpse. The cops did not happen upon Cunanan until 9:30 p.m. The forensic identification of his fingerprints did not occur until 3 a.m. the following morning. “It was extremely difficult, because he was as stiff as a board,” said Sergeant George Navarro of the Miami-Dade police. Two “nervous” technicians had to match the thumbprint to one on a pawnshop form Cunanan had signed along with a copy of his driver’s license (the original was at the FBI lab in Washington, DC.)

Another extremely annoying inaccuracy: Donatella Versace (Penélope Cruz) did not cut her brother’s partner, Antonio D’Amico (Ricky Martin), out of his inheritance, as the show clearly states.

Let’s go back to Orth’s book. “Antonio D’Amico was given approximately $30,000 a month, ‘inflation-proof,’ for life, and the privilege of living in any of Versace’s houses around the world,” she writes. “Antonio, however, told a Canadian newspaper, ‘I’ll never set foot [in those homes] because it would only be fruitless suffering.’ In a further distancing, Donatella and [Versace’s brother] Santo struck a deal with Antonio to take his monthly payments in one lump sum.”

As for the “Valley of the Dolls”-esque scene of Martin swallowing an entire bottle of blue pills, please. Orth reports D’Amico returned to Florence “to launch his own design company.”

The scenes of Marilyn Miglin (Judith Light) being warned by the FBI to clear out of Tampa, where she was on a business trip, were another Turkish Taffy stretch seemingly designed to give Light another scene for a potential Emmy campaign.

In the end, the “Versace” finale is a disappointment. The truth of the story is sufficiently tragic and moving. No one needed this melodramatic finish to drive a point home.

FX totally screwed up ‘Versace’ finale

What it’s like to play a real-life murder victim who almost escaped

Of all the five murders committed by Andrew Cunanan, the most poignant may be that of David Madson because he’s the victim who almost got away.

An architect living in Minneapolis, Madson had everything Cunanan wanted — a promising career, a good dating life, a circle of loyal friends — but didn’t want to work for. When Cunanan forced Madson, who was 33 when he was found dead at a rural lakeside in Minnesota, to flee the scene of the murder of Jeff Trail, his first victim, his doom was sealed.

As the Ryan Murphy reaches its bloody climax in a few weeks, we spoke to Australian actor Cody Fern who plays Madson about what it was like to shoot the series in reverse and to recreate that ghoulish crime scene.

Fern, who is 30, will next be seen in the sixth and final season of “House of Cards” on Netflix.

What was it like filming the storyline backwards?

You start at the most intense sequence and then you get to discover the other end of the pendulum. So it was nice to work backwards. I don’t want to get too airy-fairy, but it was nice to live out the horror of David’s life and then backtrack to something more beautiful.

Did you talk to anyone in David’s family before you started filming?

I didn’t. I’m not sure the opportunity was there.

When we were given the scripts, there was a collective feeling this was difficult to get through, especially for the families. We wanted to stay true to Maureen Orth’s book, the source material, and not stir up anything with the families through unsolicited phone calls. “I’m playing your son or brother though the most horrifying part of his life. Do you want to chat?”

Why didn’t David run?

It’s very easy to look at things objectively and say. “I would do this” or “I would do that.” When you see your best friend [Jeff Trail] murdered, 27 times with a claw hammer, you don’t know how your going to behave. The level of shock. He must have been so afraid.That was the whole linchpin of the character.

From what can be gleaned about David, he was this wonderful, generous human being. When the police were searching his apartment, they found wrapped presents for his nieces and nephews months in advance of Christmas.

You’ve been working in Baltimore on “House of Cards.” What can you tell us about your character?

I can’t say anything. There are so many rumors about my role out there. We’re not allowed to confirm. But everyone is so psyched for Robin [Wright taking over]. I think the show has been about Claire since Season Two. It’s really not a show about one man. Or Kevin Spacey’s indiscretions or his terrible secrets. It’s about Robin and Michael Kelly and Jayne Atkinson.

What it’s like to play a real-life murder victim who almost escaped

Don’t miss these March TV premieres

March 21
“Inside Look: The Assassination of Gianni Versace” finale, FX

Andrew Cunanan (Darren Criss) will be hiding out on a houseboat in the explosive finish to this tragic true-life American crime story. Versace’s (Edgar Ramírez) death was another crime the FBI might have prevented had they acted sooner on overwhelming evidence that Cunanan was in Miami after killing four men and making the 10 Most Wanted List.

Don’t miss these March TV premieres

Ricky Martin still angry cops couldn’t stop Versace killer

Ricky Martin was living in Miami when Gianni Versace was murdered in 1997.

And Martin — who plays Versace’s partner, Antonio D’Amico, in “The Assassination of Gianni Versace” — says he’s shocked by how long it took local police and the FBI to find Versace’s killer, Andrew Cunanan (Darren Criss).

“Miami’s a very small town. It’s very easy to find people,” says Martin, 46. “And [Cunanan] wasn’t even hiding.” In documenting Versace’s murder, Ryan Murphy’s FX miniseries exposes the many mistakes made as the police and FBI pursued Cunanan, who killed four men in 12 days before gunning down Versace on the steps of his South Beach mansion.

“He went to a pawn shop and sold something and showed his ID. And he signed the paper as Andrew P. Cunanan,” says Martin. “There’s a moment [in the miniseries] where the FBI agent opens the [car] trunk and you see all the [10 Most Wanted] fliers. And the other agent asks, ‘How come all these flyers are in your trunk?’”

D’Amico cradled Versace (Édgar Ramírez) on the steps of his villa after Cunanan shot him on July 14, 1997. Martin says he’d been invited “many times” to the villa, Casa Casuarina, while he lived in Miami, but that he never went — until the morning he filmed the brutal murder scene. He remained secluded inside the ornate home, “just finding the emotions and everything. And there was a moment where I said, ‘Please, say Action. I’m ready, I’m ready.’”

Martin says D’Amico spoke to him before production started about his relationship with Versace — a source of conflict with Versace’s sister Donatella (Penelope Cruz). “He told me, ‘My relationship with Gianni was beautiful and full of respect.’ He said, ‘We were free. We were open.’ If someone talked bad about Antonio, Gianni would become a lion and defend him. After 15 years, it’s not a game. It’s a real relationship.”

In the series, Donatella doesn’t see it that way, blaming D’Amico for bringing strangers into the house for threesomes. Although Martin and Cruz are friends, Martin says, “Penelope told me, ‘Ricky, you can’t be good to me because I’m not supposed to like you.’ And I would try. I would try for [Donatella] to like me. But it wasn’t happening.”

In his will, Versace left D’Amico approximately $30,000 a month, “inflation proof,” for life. According to Maureen Orth’s book, “Vulgar Favors” — the series’ source material — Donatella and her brother Santo Versace negotiated with D’Amico to take those payments in one lump sum.

“The sad thing is back then [Versace and D’Amico] couldn’t marry,” says Martin, who married his partner, Jwan Yusuf, in 2017. “If they were married, the laws would protect Antonio. And that was not the case.”

Martin dismisses the Versace company’s criticism that the series is a “work of fiction,” citing Orth’s book, including sources who say that Versace and Cunanan met seven years earlier in a San Francisco club called Colossus.

[D’Amico, who lives in Italy, has said Versace never met Cunanan.]

Martin is asked why he thinks Cunanan perpetrated his crimes, but has no concrete answer.

“No one knows. And no one will ever know,” he says. “It makes me really angry. It’s not that [Versace is] dead. It’s why did we allow it to happen.”

Ricky Martin still angry cops couldn’t stop Versace killer

Filming ‘Versace’ death scene was unsettling for Édgar Ramírez

“The Assassination of Gianni Versace” star Édgar Ramírez, who plays the murdered fashion icon in the new FX series, went to Miami a week before production began to get a feel for how Versace spent his final morning.

“I wanted to have my own experience without the basic nature of a movie set,” says Ramírez, 40. “They allowed me into the [Versace] villa [now a hotel]. I had my quiet time with the property. Then I walked the death walk. I went to the cafe [where Versace went to buy fashion magazines]. By the time I got back to the villa, I was more calm than I think I would have been if I hadn’t seen it first.”

When executive producer Ryan Murphy, Ricky Martin — who plays Versace’s companion, Antonio D’Amico — and Darren Criss, who plays Versace’s killer Andrew Cunanan, arrived on the set, the mood became “very frantic,” Ramírez says.

“[Versace] was shot at 8:45 a.m. and dead by 9:20 a.m,” he says. “It was very difficult for me not to think that everything that was going on, he was feeling it, although he was unconscious. I felt Ricky’s trembling. It was a very, very emotional scene. When they put me on the gurney and took me into the emergency room, I could feel everyone and everything. It was very difficult for me not to imagine that [Versace] was there, that he wanted to say something — goodbye, whatever.”

Versace’s death in July 1997, at the hands of serial killer Cunanan, was only the beginning of Ramírez’s journey. “The Assassination of Gianni Versace” is told out-of-sequence — from the sole encounter Versace had with Cunanan in San Francisco in 1990 to the beginning of Cunanan’s murder spree in Minneapolis three months earlier and Versace’s treatment in Miami for HIV-related illnesses.

“It was a life that was very fated,” Ramírez says. “He did think surviving AIDS was a miracle. The Catholics of the Mediterranean [believe] in a world of miracles and redemption and compassion.”

Screenwriter Tom Rob Smith also explores the conflicts Versace had with his younger sister, Donatella (Penelope Cruz), a bottom-line businesswoman who objected to her brother’s coming out. She thought such a disclosure would drive away celebrities and potential investors in the company, just as the family planned on taking it public. Versace’s response to her paranoia? “We’ll always have Elton [John].”

“It was a very volatile relationship, but a close one,” says Ramírez. “They were able to have a huge fight in the morning and then have dinner as if nothing ever happened.

“I didn’t know much about the man and the persona,” says Ramírez, who grew up in Venezuela. “The lushness and exuberance of the brand. When he was killed, then of course I knew who he was.”

Having played the role, he says he is truly moved by Versace’s global impact on the culture and the meaning of his American death. “He was the southern Italian guy going to the Milanese [fashionistas]. People from northern Italy are not Italian; they’re Swiss,” he says. “And along came this guy who spoke in a dialect people in northern Italy wouldn’t even consider Italian. And then he created this company that in 10 years took over the world.”

It was all over in an instant. “Andrew shot him in the face. He wanted to erase his humanity,” Ramírez says. “Gianni reminded him of everything he couldn’t be. They were both outsiders.

“One had the guts and the talent and the courage to do something about it.”

Filming ‘Versace’ death scene was unsettling for Édgar Ramírez

The real story behind the best ‘Versace’ looks

When the cast and crew of “The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story” attempted to recreate the life and fashion sensibility of the murdered Italian designer, immersing themselves in his flamboyant aesthetic was key to telling the story well.

So they set out to showcase his dramatic world with both setting and costume: Producer Ryan Murphy obtained permission to film the series, which debuts Wednesday on FX, inside Versace’s former home, Casa Casuarina in Miami, where the rooms are decorated with bold tile, frescoes and seashells. And actor Edgar Ramirez, who plays the doomed designer, embraced Versace’s creative vantage point, which was heavily influenced by classical motifs.

“He had a poster of the Roman empire in his shop in Calabria, [Italy,]” Ramirez said at a recent panel discussion of the series. “When we think about the Roman Empire, we tend to think about washed-out statues . . . But the reality is that the Roman Empire was very colorful. The blues were very intense and the gold was intense.”

Recreating Versace’s outlandish designs for the series became a painstaking project for Emmy-winning costume designer Lou Eyrich, who not only tracked down genuine vintage pieces, but created looks for the show without any cooperation from Gianni’s sister (and current artistic director of the brand), Donatella Versace, or the Versace company itself — which has denounced the entire production as a “work of fiction.”

“Gianni Versace was fearless and bold in his use of color. He understood the female physique and how to make a woman feel and look sexy,” says Eyrich, who has also designed the costumes for “American Horror Story.”

Versace was also fond of using mixed media in his designs. For example, a Greek key pattern seen on the border of the iron gates to his villa appears in his clothing for men. “The more you look [at his creations], the more you see [those motifs],” says Eyrich.

Since his death at age 50 in 1997, many of Versace’s pieces have been scooped up and preserved by collectors. Eyrich had to scour the Internet to outfit not only Ramirez, but Penélope Cruz, who plays Donatella, and Ricky Martin, who plays Antonio D’Amico, Versace’s domestic partner of 15 years.

Many pricey items were out of reach for Eyrich and her team: At stores such as the Way We Wore in LA, the asking price for a Versace shirt from the era is a hefty $1,500, and an animal-and-baroque-print skirt suit goes for $4,500.

“We didn’t have the budget to get the pieces we really wanted. We ordered a lot online,” Eyrich says. “We were competing with a lot of serious collectors.”

Of all the actors in the show, Ramirez was the one Eyrich was able to provide with the most authentic duds. “Almost all of Edgar’s costumes were Versace,” she says. “We sourced the jeans, the shoes and the shirts [from vintage shops]— which I’m sure he loved.”

One exception is a shocking-pink bathrobe Versace wears to breakfast at his Miami villa on the morning he’s murdered by Andrew Cunanan (Darren Criss). Eyrich had this made to Murphy’s specifications — she says the producer requested something with some “float” in it, so she used an especially lightweight silk. “When Edgar walked, it billowed,” Eyrich says.

Eyrich relied on her “genius tailor” Joanne Mills to remake a dress Versace designed for his sister — a sexy, black leather number accentuated with a series of men’s leather belts linking the bodice to a choker.

“We got every photo we could of [the original] dress,” Eyrich says of the frock that Donatella wore to a party at the New York Public Library celebrating Vogue’s centennial in 1993. “We were very careful to show our utmost respect; I didn’t want to make it look like a made-for-TV movie [design]. I want to pay tribute but not ever minimize. Joanne recreated all the hardware — the belt buckle — and made the full-leather skirt.”

Eyrich and her team also created a whopping 17 looks for a pivotal scene at Versace’s final haute couture fashion show in Paris in 1997, which plays out, in flashback, in the second episode, which airs Jan. 24. Donatella argues with her brother about the direction of their company and needles him about not being able to keep up with younger designers John Galliano and Alexander McQueen.

“You were the future, once,” she says snidely. Ever defiant, Versace tells his younger sister that great design comes “from the heart.” He reduces her to tears of shame with a runway show that unveils one inspired creation after another: A sleek, white evening gown slit up the side, a glittering red minidress and the pièce de résistance — a metallic mesh mini “wedding dress” covered with crosses, worn with a silver-headband veil. The daring piece is for the “Versace bride,” Gianni declares, not a “virginal” one.

“He had this rock ’n’ roll approach to couture,” Ramirez has said. “At this level, in high fashion, he mixed sexuality and glamour, something that, until he came along, were on two different tracks.”

The real story behind the best ‘Versace’ looks

‘Versace’ miniseries is the first great show of 2018

TV REVIEW
AMERICAN CRIME STORY: THE ASSASSINATION OF GIANNI VERSACE

★★★★

The second installment of Ryan Murphy’s “American Crime Story” franchise is the tragic tale of a globally famous gay talent and an obscure gay parasite.

Based on Maureen Orth’s “Vulgar Favors,” “The Assassination of Gianni Versace” is also a glamorous and frightening portrait of a certain kind of modern monster — the entitled kept boy who snaps when he loses the keys to what he imagined was his kingdom.

In her book, Orth describes Andrew Cunanan (Darren Criss) — who shot Gianni Versace (Edgar Ramirez) at point-blank range on the steps of his Miami villa in July 1997 — as a “narcissistic nightmare of vainglorious self-absorption, a practiced and pathological liar who … was clever enough to pull off his deceptions.”

The nine episodes of Murphy’s series, all carefully crafted by British screenwriter Tom Robb Smith (“London Spy”), track the disintegration of a spoiled child who demanded the maximum payoff for the most minimal effort — and, unable to develop any real relationships with his peers, cruelly targeted older, wealthy gay men who were willing to satisfy his endless needs.

Smith tells his story in reverse, heightening the central mystery of how a scruffy drifter with a baseball cap, backpack and gun approached Versace as he was returning from a stroll to a neighborhood cafe. Was this a random shooting, or did the younger Cunanan know the celebrated Italian fashion designer, recovering from illnesses brought on by a suppressed diagnosis of HIV? Cunanan, already infamous after landing on the FBI’s Most Wanted list following a spree that left four men, including two of his friends, dead, was bumming around Miami for two months to the apparent indifference of the local police. He then killed one last time.

As the mystery unfolds, Murphy, who directs the pilot, and Smith invite us to witness the extremes of gay culture in the 1980s and 1990s. We meet Versace’s boyfriend Antonio D’Amico (Ricky Martin), and Cunanan’s companions (and ultimate victims), former naval officer Jeff Trail (an excellent Finn Wittrock) and rising young architect David Madson (Cody Fern). We get glimpses of the Versace fashion empire with his unimaginative, controlling sister Donatella (Penelope Cruz) watching enviously as her brother silences his detractors with one ravishing creation after another. And we get a ringside seat at the twisted Cunanan home in San Diego, where Andrew’scon-man father, Pete (future Emmy winner Jon Jon Briones), sold the family home from under his wife and four children before fleeing the country on an embezzlement charge. All the tools Andrew needed to embark on his trajectory of murder and menace he learned at his father’s feet.

The performances of the leads are outstanding, but special mention must be made of Criss, who beautifully captures Cunanan’s ability to tell the biggest lies anyone has ever heard and literally charm the pants off anyone he sets his sights on. He’s a lot like Patricia Highsmith’s Mr. Ripley, but Ripley was a fictional creation. Cunanan, who committed suicide after murdering Versace, was sadly all-too-real.

Murphy’s ability to showcase well-known performers in surprising cameos continues apace with gems from Mike Farrell, Max Greenfield and even Cathy Moriarty as a wily pawnshop owner.

“The Assassination of Gianni Versace” is more personal and heartfelt than Murphy’s “The People v. O.J. Simpson,” and proves that when it comes to seductive allure laced with menace, no one in TV is Murphy’s match.

‘Versace’ miniseries is the first great show of 2018

Recreating Versace murder emotionally drained Ryan Murphy, cast and crew

Emmy-winning producer Ryan Murphy describes recreating the murder of fashion icon Gianni Versace for FX’s “The Assassination of Gianni Versace” as “one of the most emotional, profound and moving experiences” of his career.

“I never had a situation with anything I shot like this,” Murphy said recently, addressing a New York audience at a screening of the upcoming miniseries first episode. “The day we shot that the crew was crying, the actors were crying. It was very intense.”

The nine-episode miniseries premieres Jan. 17 as the next installment of FX’s “American Crime Story” anthology, and it’s already creating a lot of buzz in telling the tragic story of Versace’s 1997 murder at the hands of serial killer Andrew Cunan — who gunned Versace down on the steps outside his mansion in Miami Beach (and later killed himself).

Murphy was joined on a panel with his stars: Edgar Ramirez, who plays Versace; Darren Criss, cast as Cunanan; and Ricky Martin as Versace’s companion, Antonio D’Amico — who cradled the fallen fashion giant as he bled out from a fatal head wound in the glaring Miami sun.

Murphy filmed in front of and inside Versace’s former Miami villa, capturing the chaos and perversity of the scene: the desperation of D’Amico as he waits for help; the almost pornographic fascination of the onlookers — one of whom dips a photo of Versace in the blood left on the steps to his home — and the bewilderment of the Miami police, who have no idea what they’re getting into. Watching the scene play out on the screen at Manhattan’s Metrograph theatre had a disorienting effect on Criss.

“I was hit extremely hard by it because unlike a lot of other recreations on television it was not done on a soundstage,” he says. “Those were the stairs [of his actual house], that was the gate. It’s public access. You can walk right up to it. They have such weight, especially in the context of our story. Being dressed as Andrew was, being a beautiful Miami day.

“And then I got to walk though the damn gates and go sit in an air-conditioned room. And that hit me really hard. Andrew never got to go inside. I almost had guilt. Living with Andrew for so long, him reaching desperately for everything he couldn’t have. And there I was just walking in.”

The Versace villa is now a bed-and-breakfast. Murphy told The Post he was shocked when he received the permit to shoot there — but that the actors “were obviously delighted.”

“I don’t think I could have made the show if I couldn’t have gotten that house,” he says. “There was no way you could build [a set] of it. Two of the rooms were made out of seashells. [Gianni Versace’s sister] Donatella [Versace] took all the furniture and the art when she sold the house, but through pictures we were able to recreate them.

“It adds something to the performance.” he says. “When Edgar Ramirez goes to those Biedermeier closets [in Versace’s bedroom], they were the same closets Versace spent a year building and they’ve been lovingly maintained. They were extraordinary.”

Recreating Versace murder emotionally drained Ryan Murphy, cast and crew