The Best TV of 2018—So Far

American Crime Story: The Assassination of Gianni Versace

No series this year has a closer relationship between its form and its function than The Assassination of Gianni Versace, the second volume of Ryan Murphy’s FX anthology drama, American Crime Story. Written entirely by Tom Rob Smith, the nine-episode season tracks the murders of the world-famous designer and four other victims by Andrew Cunanan (Darren Criss), a gay man who envied Versace’s lifestyle but lacked any of the positive qualities that earned it. Assassination disarms the audience by starting where many assumed it would end, with Cunanan shooting Versace on the steps of his South Beach mansion. Smith then moves backward in time and broader in focus than the celebrity who serves as its Trojan horse, giving the three other gay men who died at Cunanan’s hands their own extended eulogies. Assassination is one of the more damning portrayals of cultural and internalized homophobia ever dramatized; by withholding an origin story for Andrew until the very end, the show throws the spotlight not just on his victims, but on the society that created him. No wonder it didn’t become a smash hit. — Herman

The Best TV of 2018—So Far

Pierce: What are the best shows on TV? Critics don’t agree

There’s a misperception out there that TV critics are some sort of monolith. That there’s some sort of critical consensus.

To prove that wrong, you need look no further than the nominees for this year’s Television Critics Association Awards — which include a few shows I don’t much care for, one that troubles me greatly and one I absolutely loathe.

Don’t get me wrong. The TCA Awards are more legit than, say, the Emmys, because they’re given by people who actually watch almost everything on TV. (Nobody can watch everything anymore.)

And I’ll happily endorse the overwhelming majority of the TCA Awards nominees.

But I’m not a big fan of “Bill” or “GLOW.” And this might get me in trouble, but I’m kind of over “The Handmaid’s Tale” after Season 2.

I’ve also been stewing over “The Assassination of Gianni Versace” for months. The more I think about it, the more I’m troubled by the fact that so much of the supposed docudrama was complete fiction.

Pierce: What are the best shows on TV? Critics don’t agree

The best TV dramas of 2018 so far

From epic fantasy and science fiction, to hard-hitting stories grounded in the here and now, it’s been a terrific year for television so far in 2018. 

As we near the mid-point of the year, here, in no particular order, are the best TV dramas that have been broadcast in the UK so far.

The Assassination Of Gianni Versace

Following a phenomenal dramatic take on OJ Simpson’s trial, American Crime Story had a lot to live up to with its second offering of real-life murder turned media circus. But it was mostly a success: Darren Criss’s performance as killer Andrew Cunanan proved utterly riveting, while Penelope Cruz’s transformation into Donatella Versace gave her a role with which to gleefully break type.

The best TV dramas of 2018 so far

5 Best LGBTQ Shows of 2018 So Far

THE ASSASSINATION OF GIANNI VERSACE: AMERICAN CRIME STORY

The second season of Ryan Murphy’s ripped-from-the-headlines drama American Crime Story took us inside the 1997 assassination of Gianni Versace, and it was just about as gay as a show can get. Sure, the main queer character in this was actually a serial-killing psychopath, but hey, this was based on real life — we can’t all be good! While telling the backstory behind Andrew Cunanan’s murder spree, we got a chilling reminder of the homophobia that existed in the ’90s, with the FBI not bothering to engage the gay community during their investigation and with Versace feeling the pressure to not come out of the closet. Plus, we had out musician Ricky Martin in the role of Versace’s longtime lover, Antonio D’Amico. Twentygayteen, indeed.

5 Best LGBTQ Shows of 2018 So Far

Should Phil Collins Be Celebrated or Vilified?

One of the most memorable scenes from The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story, FX’s brilliant and underwatched 2018 miniseries, concerns Andrew Cunanan (Darren Criss) and a wealthy older man who thinks he has hired Cunanan to have sex with him in his Miami hotel room. What the man doesn’t know is that Cunanan is a fugitive serial killer who will soon murder the world’s most famous fashion designer. Cunanan has decided to torture his would-be john with some duct tape, a pair of scissors, and “Easy Lover,” 1984’s hit duet that Collins performed and cowrote with Philip Bailey.

The appearance of “Easy Lover” in The Assassination of Gianni Versace reveals new layers to Cunanan as well as the song. Setting aside the obvious logistical problems — why would Cunanan pack Bailey’s Chinese Wall CD for his cross-country crime spree, on the off chance that he would want to play it during an assault? — the song perfectly spotlights how the killer’s delusional megalomania fed his increasingly homicidal behavior. Criss’s ecstatic arm-waving to this frothy pop tune, moving in time with Collins’s titanic drum beat, while his prey slowly suffocates, is both chilling and darkly comic. The walls are closing in on Cunanan, but he will not be deterred from relishing his mayhem in the meantime.

As for “Easy Lover,” The Assassination of Gianni Versace teases out the song’s dark subtext, and then completely reinvents it. At the scene’s climax, Cunanan straddles his would-be customer, raising the scissors above his head. As he plunges the blade into the duct tape covering the man’s mouth, finally allowing him to breathe, Collins’s screaming vocal lifts on the soundtrack: “You’ll be down on your knees!” Whoa. Was that in “Easy Lover” from the beginning?

Should Phil Collins Be Celebrated or Vilified?

https://api.soundcloud.com/tracks/460258983/stream?client_id=N2eHz8D7GtXSl6fTtcGHdSJiS74xqOUI?plead=please-dont-download-this-or-our-lawyers-wont-let-us-host-audio

Episode 47: Assassination of Gianni Versace and The Prince & the Dressmaker (plus MEN’s World Cup)

In Episode 47, Heather and Bennett talk about Ryan Murphy’s American Crime Story: The Assassination of Gianni Versace starring Darren Criss, and the graphic novel “The Prince and the Dressmaker” by Jen Wang.

Other topics include: the Minneapolis raccoon, Millie Bobby Brown, Immigration, Nick Offerman, the World Cup, Phil Mickleson, Natalie Portman, Hiro Mirai, and Wonder Woman 1984. | 19 June 2018

*from 29:50 to 52:22

Rotten Tomatoes 10 highest rated TV series for your Pride viewing pleasure

9. The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story (2018) – 86%

The Ryan Murphy anthology series returned this season, reimaging one of the most shocking murders in American history. Though the show features a cast that includes Oscar winner Penelope Cruz, Ricky Martin, Edgar Ramirez, and Judith Light, the series belongs to Darren Criss as spree killer Andrew Cunanan. Criss captures the imbalance of the character, making him all the more despicable. While the series in no way absolves Cunanan of his crimes, it also has a preoccupation with the rampant homophobia of the time, ranging from Donatella Versace’s disgust with her brother’s lover, to the FBI claiming Cunanan had evaded escape by posing as a woman (yes, it really happened). This opera of a show plays just as infuriating as it does tragic.

Rotten Tomatoes 10 highest rated TV series for your Pride viewing pleasure

Reflecting on ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ and More TV That Dares You to Stop Watching

The latest series of Ryan Murphy’s American Crime Story, The Assassination of Gianni Versace, started with the savage and bloody murder of the Italian fashion icon, played out backwards and still ended up more depressing than it started. To embark on a new TV box set these days is to expose yourself to approximately 10 hours of doom, gloom and heartbreak.

Reflecting on ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ and More TV That Dares You to Stop Watching

Donatella Versace’s counterblast to American Crime Story on Bloomsday

Discussions on a possible replacement, successor or assistant to Donatella had been the leitmotif of Versace shows for the past year. This snappily staged show was all the better for the lack of such talk. Instead its main message was the way the clothes were splattered with graphics. Tabloid-style covers from a daily known as The Versace, with headlines like Super Exclusive! Or Versace Finally Speaks!

Clear references to the TV series American Crime Story: The Assassination of Gianni Versace. In a statement in January, the house stressed that the Versace family “had neither authorized nor had any involvement in the TV series,” and that it “should be treated as a work of fiction.”

Presented under a brilliantly imagined arbor of hanging wisteria on a Perspex catwalk in the courtyard of the house’s historic palazzo on via Gesù. Backed up by a punchy soundtrack, including the driving Inhliziyo by Faka; and a top notch cast, starring a particularly aloof Kendall Jenner – poured eye-bogglingly into a great chain, jewel and tropical floral print mini dress – and Bella Hadid in a miniature ruffled black leather dress.

All told, there was nothing terribly wrong with this co-ed collection and indeed it had plenty of hip and attractive fashion. But it did lack any proper drama and real excitement – two qualities one has come to expect from the Medusa house.

One could only admire the cool chalk stripe suits in pale gray where the stripe was made up of mini Versaces; or the day-glow pastel suits in neon pink and neon green. However, it was strange to witness a Versace runway collection that reminded one, if anything, of Supreme. That New York streetwear brand has been all over Italian catwalks this year, but one did not expect it in Versace.

At the end, Donatella took a dazzling bow. Clearly in charge, looking her audience right in the eye, after more or less closing her back stage for 12 months.

How accurate was the TV series on the truly awful death of her brother? Ultimately, it was much more about the dark loser Andrew Cunanan who went on a killing spree across America before tragically shooting Gianni in Miami.

Quite frankly, speaking as someone who met, interviewed, dined with and attended parties thrown by Gianni, I found the series visually very accurate. Its sound, on the other hand, felt all wrong. Despite dutiful performances, Hispanic actors – none of whom sounded remotely Italian – played all the key characters of Donatella, Gianni and his partner Antonio D’Amico. Which was telling, seeing as today is June 16, and Bloomsday, the day when the action takes places in Dublin in James Joyce’s Ulysses, the greatest English-language novel of the 20th century. Imagine asking a bunch of Welshmen to play all the Irishman in a TV series of Ulysses. Wouldn’t work would it? Didn’t work in the TV series either.

See catwalk

Donatella Versace’s counterblast to American Crime Story on Bloomsday

Emmys 2018: Outstanding Limited Series — Our 5 Dream Nominees!

Last year, Emmy’s Outstanding Limited Series contest was about as suspenseful as any kudos race featuring Julia Louis-Dreyfus. Basically, HBO’s soapy phenom Big Little Lies had the win in the bag. But this year? The statue is completely up for grabs.

Our Dream Emmy lineup, meanwhile, boasts a mix of high-profile minis and a few under-the-radar gems. All five contenders have one thing in common: They polarized audiences — Team TVLine included.

For the record, 2018 Emmy nominations will be voted on from June 11-25, and unveiled on July 12. The 70th Primetime Emmy Awards ceremony, hosted by Colin Jost and Michael Che, is scheduled to air Monday, Sept. 17, on NBC.

THE ASSASSINATION OF GIANNI VERSACE: AMERICAN CRIME STORY

WHY IT DESERVES A NOD: Anchored by Darren Criss in a star-making turn as serial killer Andrew Cunanan, the nine-part second installment in FX’s American Crime Story franchise spun a captivating tale of desperation and despair against stunning, sumptuous backdrops — making it as difficult to watch as it was impossible to look away from. Throw in unforgettable performances from the likes of Judith Light, Penelope Cruz and Max Greenfield, and you’ve got yourself a miniseries to die for.

Emmys 2018: Outstanding Limited Series — Our 5 Dream Nominees!