3. ‘The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story’ (FX)
The latest “American Crime Story” adaptation is a misnomer, as it follows (mostly in reverse chronological order) the life of Versace’s murderer, Andrew Cunanan. But as played in a tour de force and award-worthy performance by Darren Criss, Cunanan’s and Versace’s (Edgar Ramirez) interwoven stories are riveting and revealing, a study of the lives and struggles of gay men in the 1990s. At times difficult to watch, the portrait of the spree killer is gilded and fascinating, gorgeous and off-putting from beginning to end.
Tag: usa today
USA Today Life Critic’s Corner | 26 March 2018
Why the ‘Versace’ season of ‘American Crime Story’ never caught on like ‘O.J.’
Andrew Cunanan (Darren Criss) killed himself in Wednesday’s operatic, devastating season finale of FX’s The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story. But you might have missed it.
The second season of FX and Ryan Murphy’s American Crime Story anthology was a darkly gorgeous series, as it followed spree killer Cunanan in reverse chronological order, starting with his infamous murder of fashion designer Versace and spinning backward to his disturbing childhood. Then the last episode finally cycled back to the July 15, 1997 death of Versace, after which Cunanan evaded police capture for a few days until he was discovered and ultimately killed himself.
Over its nine episodes this winter, Versace has been harrowing to watch unfold. Criss has put in a tour-de-force performance as Cunanan, managing to make the spree killer disturbing, fascinating and even slightly sympathetic as the writers dove into his life and murders. The season had a host of excellent supporting performances, especially from Judith Light, who returned in the finale after first appearing in the third episode as the widow of one of Cunanan’s victims.
So why did the Versace season seem to air in a bubble, never garnering the ratings or buzz that The People vs. O.J. Simpson did just two years ago?
It was always going to be like this.
In 2016, the retelling of the Simpson trial felt especially apt to our modern era, so much so that the FX series was not the only wildly successful portrayal – O.J.: Made in America, an ESPN documentary about his life, went on to win an Oscar. As a country, we were (and still are) grappling with systemic racism, police violence, celebrity politics and all that comes with those subjects.
Versace got political, too, especially in its portrayal of Cunanan and his victims’ experience as gay men in the 1990s, the era of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell and the Defense of Marriage Act. The finale emphasized this, as Ronnie (Max Greenfield), a friend of Cunanan’s, criticized police for ignoring the killer and his victims because they were gay. Another powerful episode showed one of his victims, Jeff Trail (Finn Wittrock), trying to hide his sexuality as a naval officer. It was powerful stuff, but it just never felt quite as essential as O.J. did.
Although the Versace story was well done, it was about a less well-known crime than O.J., it was more violent and focused more on the killer than the victim whose name was in the title.
The problem with starting a series with a cultural milestone as big as the trial of O.J. Simpson is that the only place to go is down.
Why the ‘Versace’ season of ‘American Crime Story’ never caught on like ‘O.J.’
Q&A: Matt Bomer on directing ‘Versace,’ ‘Boys in the Band’ and a ‘White Collar’ reunion
Actor Matt Bomer is central to Wednesday’s penultimate episode of FX’s The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story (10 ET/PT), but viewers won’t see him. He’s playing a new role: director.
Bomer (White Collar, The Normal Heart), 40, spoke to USA TODAY about his first-time gig directing the episode, “Creator/Destroyer,” which looks at designer Versace and his killer, Andrew Cunanan, as pre-teens; working with his mega-producer friend Ryan Murphy; and the chances for a revival of his USA hit, White Collar.
Question: How did this first-time directing assignment come about?
Bomer: I’d worked with Ryan several times. He knew I always would come into the set with reams of text work and research and he said, ‘You should direct.’ I thought it might be on American Horror Story, but he said Versace. I promptly passed out. When I came to, I said, ‘Yes.’ This was a four-month labor of love for me. I read over 3,000 pages of books. I met with director friends to get insight. I did an intensive with the DGA (Directors Guild of America). I shadowed two other directors of the show. So by the time I got on set, I was at least able to fake it till I made it.
Q: How did you approach Cunanan in this episode, which portrays a future killer and a future fashion icon as youths?
Bomer: “We’re all responsible for the choices we make, but it was a big question of this episode: Can we empathize with a monster when we see the circumstances of his life and the hand he was dealt? What makes one person a creator and one a killer?
Q&A: Matt Bomer on directing ‘Versace,’ ‘Boys in the Band’ and a ‘White Collar’ reunion
TV tonight: ‘Survivor’ tries to ‘reverse the curse’ in new season
The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story
FX, 10 ET/PTAs the series continues moving backward in time, we get to know more about spree killer Andrew Cunanan’s (Darren Criss) backstory and the how he became intertwined with the men he would later kill. Tonight’s episode shows Cunanan at a particularly desperate period of his life and depicts the beginnings of his relationship with David Madson (Cody Fern), with whom he becomes obsessed. Criss’ performance remains unsettling, managing to make Cunanan terrifying even in episodes without scenes of violence.
TV tonight: ‘Survivor’ tries to ‘reverse the curse’ in new season
Do villains get too much of the spotlight (and empathy) in ‘Versace,’ ‘Waco’ and ‘Tonya’?
Maybe crime really doesn’t pay, but it seems tougher to make that argument with the recent spate of film and TV projects highlighting real people best known for their worst actions.
Historical names and events — Gianni Versace, the Waco siege, Harding vs. Kerrigan — draw viewers’ attention, but writers often change details or shift focus, softening the rougher edges of the transgressor or losing sight of the victims.
FX’s limited series The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story (Wednesdays, 10 ET/PT), is less about the acclaimed Italian designer than Andrew Cunanan, the man famous for his brutal killings of five men, including the fashion icon.
As Paramount Network’s Waco (Wednesdays, 10 ET/PT) reveals a side of Branch Davidian leader David Koresh that it claims government and the media missed, the series treads lightly regarding allegations that he had sex with underage girls.
And Oscar nominee I, Tonya (in theaters now), which cavalierly jokes about its accuracy, recasts figure skater Tonya Harding, convicted of hindering prosecution after the assault of rival Nancy Kerrigan, as a spiky underdog.
All these projects make commendable points. Versace examines anti-gay bigotry in law enforcement and society; Waco looks at questions of faith, freedom and government power; and I, Tonya depicts the toll of class discrimination and domestic violence.
But in the process, each raises the profile of people we wouldn’t remember if not for their bad acts. Dead or alive, that’s a big status bump in a society obsessed with celebrity.
The biggest problem is how they highlight the perpetrator while giving less attention to those who have been wronged. Both Versace and Waco flesh out the victims to a degree, but the FX miniseries is ultimately killer Cunanan’s story and Waco’s focus on Koresh overshadows the depiction of his fellow Branch Davidians, limiting our ability to know and feel for them.
At least they try. Although Harding’s misdeed isn’t remotely comparable to the actions of Cunanan or Koresh, the contrast between Harding and Kerrigan in I, Tonya is the most galling.
Olympic silver medalist Kerrigan, whose injury at the hands of people connected to Harding is the reason we remember this rivalry, is treated as a whiny afterthought. Her dialogue consists of the famous anguished question — “Why? Why?” — while the film’s namesake was recently thanked from the stage at the Golden Globes. Something’s wrong here.
We’re now accustomed to more honest, shaded portrayals: heroes with flaws and villains who aren’t entirely evil. But when actors or writers attempt to make their characters more empathetic, they can unintentionally burnish a wrongdoer’s image.
“It’s my job to be empathetic. If I set out to paint him as a monster, then there’s no point in telling the story. This isn’t a Bond villain,” says Darren Criss, who plays Cunanan.
Viewers may connect more, too, when real-life bad actors are played by better-looking professionals: Criss as Cunanan; Taylor Kitsch as Koresh; and Margot Robbie as Harding. We’re drawn to good-looking people and tend to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Humanity’s dark side is fascinating, with great storytelling appeal. Just look at some of the best shows of TV’s current golden age, including Mad Men, The Sopranos and Game of Thrones. But it’s less complicated when the character in question is a work of fiction.
Real people — both perpetrators and victims — make for great stories, too, but there’s a responsibility to get them right. Ideally, viewers would use films and TV shows as jumping-off points to learn more about the subjects. Unfortunately, for many it’s too often the only source of information.
A good start would be to find out more about those who don’t get the attention they deserve.
Go beyond Versace’s depiction of the fashion genius and his brave decision to live openly as a gay man. Learn more about him and Cunanan’s other victims.
Think of the others, especially the children, who died at Waco’s Branch Davidian compound and find out more about religious cults and offshoots.
And read up on the impressive skating accomplishments of Kerrigan, who faced her own challenges but somehow managed to reach skating’s pinnacle — and, unlike her rival, avoid a criminal conviction in the process.
We can hope they’ll all get a TV show or a movie, but we know that’s not going to happen. They’re not doing anything bad.
Do villains get too much of the spotlight (and empathy) in ‘Versace,’ ‘Waco’ and ‘Tonya’?
TV tonight: A harrowing episode of ‘The Assassination of Gianni Versace’
The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story
FX, 10 ET/PTThe unsettling second season of American Crime Story is slowly revealing the story of spree killer Andrew Cunanan (Darren Criss), and this episode focuses entirely on one of his earlier victims, Chicago real estate magnate Lee Miglin (Mike Farrell). The episode, one of the best of the season, is occasionally hard to watch. But Judith Light puts in an exceptional performance as Miglin’s devoted wife Marilyn, whose hard exterior is broken by the violent crime. Of all nine episodes, this one feels almost like a short film, more about Lee than his killer.
TV tonight: A harrowing episode of ‘The Assassination of Gianni Versace’
Review: FX’s ‘The Assassination of Gianni Versace’ will unnerve you
The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story isn’t what you might expect.
Stylish and vivid, violent and colorful, the newest installment of FX’s American Crime Story anthology series (Wednesday, 10 ET/PT, ★ ★ ★ ½ out of four) is not a courtroom drama like 2016’s The People vs. O.J. Simpson. Nor is it really the story of the death of Gianni Versace, the famed fashion designer who was shot dead on the steps of his Miami Beach villa in 1997.
Instead, the nine-episode series, from executive producers Ryan Murphy and Tom Rob Smith, based on the book Vulgar Favors by Maureen Orth, is the story of serial killer Andrew Cunanan, who claimed Versace as his fifth and final victim. The series spins backward in time, peeling back the layers of one of America’s most enigmatic killers, brought to life with disturbing energy and commitment by Darren Criss, who has decidedly left his wholesome Glee character in the dust.
The series unfolds like the operas for which Versace designed costumes. Its first moments are also Versace’s (Edgar Ramirez) last, as they chronicle the fateful morning when he was shot by Cunanan and mourned by his lover Antonio D’Amico (Ricky Martin) and sister Donatella (Penélope Cruz).
Soon, the series leaves the Versaces behind to focus on Cunanan, occasionally weaving in flashbacks to Gianni’s childhood and ascent to fashion stardom. Whether it’s responsible to give a killer a starring role is never quite examined, at least not in the first eight episodes. Each takes a step backward in Cunanan’s life, including his murders of Lee Miglin (Mike Farrell), David Madson (Cody Fern), Jeff Trail (Finn Wittrock) and William Reese (Gregg Lawrence). And eventually the series travels back to Cunanan’s troubled childhood to decode the man.
Cunanan is a grotesquely fascinating figure, but Versace’s weakness, especially compared to People vs. O.J., is that his life (and death) wasn’t eventful enough to to devote nine episodes. Cunanan’s tale is simpler, with fewer points of view than the O.J. saga. The series’ reverse chronology is captivating, but it occasionally confuses the events in the killer’s life.
Versace zeroes in on the struggles gay people faced in the 1990s, from the police homophobia it argues derailed the manhunt, or a side story about the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy, but some of the moments are too heavy-handed.
However, the series’ strengths lie in its spectacle. Murphy has a knack for grandiosity, and, as with American Horror Story, Versace marries the extravagant with the violent. Even when the series stretches its plot too thin, bold direction mostly makes up for it, ensuring that there is always something to look at, either beautiful or repulsive.
The series is grounded by sublime performances from its cast, led by Criss (and we’re guessing the Emmys will notice); Martin, the singer whose deft and subtle acting skills may surprise viewers who missed him in Spanish-language TV; and Cruz, whose portrayal of Donatella never borders on cartoonish.
Versace will inevitably be compared to People vs. O.J., so it’s better that it stands apart from the earlier Emmy-winning chapter. What it does well, it does extremely well, and its mix of beauty and horror will stick with you long after its episodes conclude.
Review: FX’s ‘The Assassination of Gianni Versace’ will unnerve you
Darren Criss, far from ‘Glee,’ takes darker turn as Gianni Versace’s killer
Darren Criss doesn’t have to worry that he’ll be forever typecast as that cute, preppy singer from Glee.
FX’s limited series, The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story (Wednesday, 10 ET/PT) roughs up that wholesome image.
Versace, a follow-up to last year’s Emmy-winning O.J. Simpson courtroom saga, recounts Cunanan’s 1997 murder spree, which claimed five lives as the 27-year-old traversed the country, ending with the iconic fashion designer outside his mansion in Miami Beach.
Criss, 30, best known as Warblers singer and Kurt’s lover (and eventual husband) Blaine Anderson on Glee, reunites with executive producer Ryan Murphy on a darker story with a bigger, weightier role.
“I had a great time doing Blaine, (but he) is part of a more ensemble piece,” he says. “It was nice to be on a bigger playing field with Ryan and to get our hands dirty.”
Murphy said Criss was the first actor he cast for the pivotal role in Versace, based on Maureen Orth’s book, Vulgar Favors. The high-powered cast also includes Oscar winner Penelope Cruz as Versace’s sister, Donatella, and Ricky Martin as his partner, Antonio D’Amico.
Criss acting against his Glee image works well in Versace, executive producer Nina Jacobson says.
People might ask, “How could that (Glee) guy be this guy? (just as) the people who knew Andrew said, ‘How can that guy be this guy?’ “ she says.
Criss has a likability but also an ability to go darker, Jacobson says. “Andrew was not your garden-variety psychopath, torturing animals as a child. He was well-liked, warm, connected to people. To watch his descent and see his humanity but still never excuse his actions, I thought Darren just had that: the glibness, on one hand, and the depth.”
Criss, a San Francisco native who has been playing musical instruments since childhood, likens being part of the troupe Murphy calls on for his various projects to the repertory nature of the American Conservatory Theater, where he was accepted to a youth program.
Criss says Murphy first mentioned the Cunanan role to him three years ago.
“Lady Gaga had just been announced to do American Horror Story, and so I remember jokingly saying to him, ‘Well, let me know if you need a wily bellhop to run around.’ I was kind of joking — but not,” says Criss, who appeared in two episodes of that season’s AHS: Hotel. “He said, ‘I’m doing this O.J. (story). It’s more of a courtroom drama and I really want to do a manhunt. I want to do this Versace-Cunanan story. How much do you know about him?‘ ”
Criss felt an obligation to understand the well-educated gay man, whom the series portrays as initially killing out of personal passion but later adopting more political motives. Versace, one of the most prominent openly gay men of that time, was his final victim before he took his own life on a houseboat, a week later.
“It’s my job to be empathetic. If I set out to paint him as a monster, then there’s no point in telling the story. This isn’t a Bond villain,” he says.
Criss shares some surface similarities with Cunanan: Each is from California, has a parent from the Philippines and is college educated.
With an education, friends, a gift for storytelling (or lying) and no history of social problems, why did Cunanan become a murderer?
Orth suggested the young man was willing to kill to become famous and that he envied Versace, who had the fame, riches and romantic relationship he desired.
That contrast is emphasized in the Versace, writer Tom Rob Smith told the Television Critics Association.
“This is a story of two men born in very different circumstances, a lot of similarities, both gay, both understood that they could be destroyed at any point, and how one person navigates that destruction by building this amazing empire and how he protects against homophobia by surrounding himself with money and power and success, and (how) someone else who fails to do that, who is then destroyed.”
Cunanan had disadvantages and setbacks that many others encounter without suffering such “an extreme fall from grace,” Criss says. “There are things that happened with him that would have changed most people and made them think about their lives differently, whereas Andrew, instead of facing reality, continued to cover it up with more lies and more fantasy that would ultimately” lead to tragedy.
Darren Criss, far from ‘Glee,’ takes darker turn as Gianni Versace’s killer
Why title of FX’s Versace series doesn’t call murderer by his name
PASADENA, Calif. — Producers didn’t casually choose the title of the second installment of FX’s crime anthology series: The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story (Jan. 17, 10 ET/PT).
“It was a political murder,” executive producer Ryan Murphy told the Television Critics Association Friday. Killer Andrew Cunanan went after gay men “to shame them and out them,” and fashion icon Versace, who was openly gay, was a prime target.
So the title doesn’t include the culprit’s name, because identifying Cunanan would be “elevating him to a place we didn’t want to put him in,” executive producer and writer Tom Rob Smith said. (Versace, his fifth and final victim, is also more well known).
The new season tracks Cunanan (Darren Criss, Glee) on a 1997 cross-country murder spree that resulted in at least five killings, culminating with the shooting of Versace (Edgar Ramirez, Hands of Stone) in Miami’s South Beach.
Penelope Cruz plays Gianni’s famous sister, Donatella, and pop star Ricky Martin plays Gianni’s boyfriend, Antonio D’Amico.
Versace, which FX describes as “inspired by actual events,” is based on Maureen Orth’s book, Vulgar Favors.
Homophobia plays a role in law enforcement’s slow response in pursuing Cunanan, who murdered four others before arriving in Miami, executive producer Nina Jacobson said.
Versace “did not have to die. Cunanan was out clubbing right across the street from the police department” before the shooting, she said.
The first ACS installment, 2016’s The People v. O.J. Simpson, was a big hit for FX, nabbing 10 Emmys.
“Every season of the show will have a different tonality. The first season was very much a courtroom potboiler. The second season is a manhunt thriller,” Murphy said. The delayed Katrina season, originally due before Versace, will focus on a hospital and examine the condition of “medical (care) in our country, global warming, who lives and who dies.”
Why title of FX’s Versace series doesn’t call murderer by his name